Using Other Bankruptcy Prediction Models

Oct 13, 2025 by miodeya.com 147 views

Analysis of the Effect of Bank Bankruptcy on the Stock Prices of Banking Companies on the Indonesia Stock Exchange Using the Altman Z-Score Method

Introduction

Banks as financial institutions have the main objective to generate profits. In an effort to achieve these goals, bank management must be able to control various operational activities, especially those related to the company's finances. One way to do this is through bankruptcy prediction analysis using financial ratios, namely Altman Z-Score. Bankruptcy prediction analysis is a crucial aspect of bank management as it helps in identifying potential financial problems and taking corrective measures to prevent them. In this study, we aim to analyze the effect of bank bankruptcy on the share price of banking companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange using the Altman Z-Score method.

The Importance of Bankruptcy Prediction Analysis

Bankruptcy prediction analysis is a critical tool for bank management as it helps in identifying potential financial problems and taking corrective measures to prevent them. The Altman Z-Score method is a widely used bankruptcy prediction model that uses five financial ratios to predict the likelihood of a company's bankruptcy. The five ratios used in the Altman Z-Score method are:

X1: Working Capital/Total Assets: This ratio measures a company's ability to pay its short-term debts.
X2: Retained Earnings/Total Assets: This ratio measures a company's profitability and ability to generate cash.
X3: Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT)/Total Assets: This ratio measures a company's profitability and ability to generate cash.
X4: Market Value of Equity/Book Value of Debt: This ratio measures a company's leverage and ability to meet its debt obligations.
X5: Sales/Total Assets: This ratio measures a company's ability to generate sales and revenue.

Research Methodology

In this study, the data used was secondary data which included financial information and share prices of banking companies from 2005 to 2009. The research population consisted of banking companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange, with sampling techniques carried out purposive sampling. The result was obtained 20 banking companies that were the object of research.

Research Result

The results of this study indicate a positive and significant relationship between bank bankruptcy and the share price of banking companies on the Indonesia Stock Exchange. This indicates that when a bank indicated bankruptcy, its share price tends to decline. Conversely, the bank that is declared healthy according to Z-Score analysis will be more likely to maintain or even increase its share price.

Analysis and Explanation

The use of the Altman Z-Score method in predicting bank bankruptcy is very relevant considering the indicators used include various aspects of financial performance, such as liquidity, profitability, and leverage. In this context, the ratios provide a clear picture of the financial health of a bank.

When investors get negative information about the financial health of a bank, they tend to reduce their share ownership, which in turn led to a decrease in stock prices. Therefore, it is important for bank management to carry out risk mitigation strategies, including better financial management and transparency in financial statements to maintain investor confidence.

Conclusion

In the banking world, bankruptcy analysis using Altman Z-Score is not only useful for identifying internal problems, but also has a direct impact on market reactions reflected in stock prices. Therefore, it is important for bank investors and management to understand and utilize this analysis in making their decisions. This study strengthens the understanding that bank financial health is not only an internal responsibility, but also affects market perceptions and confidence in the value of the bank's shares.

Recommendations

Based on the findings of this study, the following recommendations are made:

Bank Management: Bank management should utilize the Altman Z-Score method to predict potential financial problems and take corrective measures to prevent them.
Investors: Investors should consider the financial health of a bank before making investment decisions.
Regulatory Bodies: Regulatory bodies should ensure that banks maintain transparency in their financial statements and adhere to sound financial management practices.

Limitations of the Study

This study has several limitations, including:

Data Limitation: The study used secondary data from 2005 to 2009, which may not reflect the current financial situation of banks.
Sample Size: The study used a sample size of 20 banking companies, which may not be representative of the entire banking industry.

Future Research Directions

Future research should focus on:

Updating the Altman Z-Score Model: The Altman Z-Score model should be updated to reflect the current financial situation of banks.
Using Other Bankruptcy Prediction Models: Other bankruptcy prediction models, such as the Zmijewski model, should be used to compare the results with the Altman Z-Score model.
Analyzing the Impact of Bankruptcy on Other Financial Metrics: The impact of bankruptcy on other financial metrics, such as credit ratings and loan defaults, should be analyzed.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on the Analysis of the Effect of Bank Bankruptcy on the Stock Prices of Banking Companies on the Indonesia Stock Exchange Using the Altman Z-Score Method

Q: What is the Altman Z-Score method?

A: The Altman Z-Score method is a widely used bankruptcy prediction model that uses five financial ratios to predict the likelihood of a company's bankruptcy. The five ratios used in the Altman Z-Score method are:

X1: Working Capital/Total Assets: This ratio measures a company's ability to pay its short-term debts.
X2: Retained Earnings/Total Assets: This ratio measures a company's profitability and ability to generate cash.
X3: Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT)/Total Assets: This ratio measures a company's profitability and ability to generate cash.
X4: Market Value of Equity/Book Value of Debt: This ratio measures a company's leverage and ability to meet its debt obligations.
X5: Sales/Total Assets: This ratio measures a company's ability to generate sales and revenue.

Q: What is the purpose of using the Altman Z-Score method in predicting bank bankruptcy?

A: The purpose of using the Altman Z-Score method in predicting bank bankruptcy is to identify potential financial problems and take corrective measures to prevent them. The Altman Z-Score method provides a clear picture of the financial health of a bank, which is essential in making informed investment decisions.

Q: How does the Altman Z-Score method affect the share price of banking companies?

A: The Altman Z-Score method has a direct impact on market reactions reflected in stock prices. When a bank is predicted to be bankrupt using the Altman Z-Score method, its share price tends to decline. Conversely, the bank that is declared healthy according to Z-Score analysis will be more likely to maintain or even increase its share price.

Q: What are the limitations of the Altman Z-Score method?

A: The Altman Z-Score method has several limitations, including:

Data Limitation: The study used secondary data from 2005 to 2009, which may not reflect the current financial situation of banks.
Sample Size: The study used a sample size of 20 banking companies, which may not be representative of the entire banking industry.

Q: What are the recommendations for bank management, investors, and regulatory bodies based on the findings of this study?

A: Based on the findings of this study, the following recommendations are made:

Bank Management: Bank management should utilize the Altman Z-Score method to predict potential financial problems and take corrective measures to prevent them.
Investors: Investors should consider the financial health of a bank before making investment decisions.
Regulatory Bodies: Regulatory bodies should ensure that banks maintain transparency in their financial statements and adhere to sound financial management practices.

Q: What are the future research directions based on the findings of this study?

A: Future research should focus on:

Updating the Altman Z-Score Model: The Altman Z-Score model should be updated to reflect the current financial situation of banks.
Using Other Bankruptcy Prediction Models: Other bankruptcy prediction models, such as the Zmijewski model, should be used to compare the results with the Altman Z-Score model.
Analyzing the Impact of Bankruptcy on Other Financial Metrics: The impact of bankruptcy on other financial metrics, such as credit ratings and loan defaults, should be analyzed.

Q: What are the implications of this study for the banking industry?

A: The findings of this study have significant implications for the banking industry, including:

Improved Risk Management: Banks should utilize the Altman Z-Score method to predict potential financial problems and take corrective measures to prevent them.
Increased Transparency: Banks should maintain transparency in their financial statements and adhere to sound financial management practices.
Better Investment Decisions: Investors should consider the financial health of a bank before making investment decisions.

Q: What are the implications of this study for regulatory bodies?

A: The findings of this study have significant implications for regulatory bodies, including:

Enhanced Supervision: Regulatory bodies should ensure that banks maintain transparency in their financial statements and adhere to sound financial management practices.
Improved Regulation: Regulatory bodies should update their regulations to reflect the current financial situation of banks.
Increased Enforcement: Regulatory bodies should increase enforcement of regulations to prevent bank failures.