Use a Quantitative Approach

Oct 13, 2025 by miodeya.com 11 views

Effectiveness of the Implementation of Medan City Regional Regulation No. 3 of 2014 concerning Non-Smoking Areas in Medan Millennium Mall in 2018

Introduction

The implementation of non-smoking areas (KTR) in Medan City is regulated in Medan City Regional Regulation No. 3 of 2014. The purpose of this policy is to create a clean and healthy space and environment, and provide protection to the people from the adverse effects of cigarettes, both directly and not directly. The regulation aims to designate seven places as KTR, which must be free from cigarette smoke. However, despite the regulation, many violations occur, indicating that the implementation has not been maximized. This study aims to analyze the effectiveness of the implementation of the regional regulation at the Medan Millennium Mall in 2018.

Background

Medan City Regional Regulation No. 3 of 2014 is a policy aimed at creating a clean and healthy environment in Medan City. The regulation designates seven places as KTR, which must be free from cigarette smoke. The implementation of this policy is crucial in protecting the public from the adverse effects of cigarettes. However, despite the regulation, many violations occur, indicating that the implementation has not been maximized. The Millennium Mall is one of the designated KTR areas, but the implementation of this policy is still encountered obstacles.

Methodology

This study uses a qualitative approach with the phenomenological method to analyze the effectiveness of the implementation of the regional regulation at the Millennium Mall in 2018. Data was collected through in-depth interviews, documentation studies, and observations. The informants in this study consisted of ten people, including representatives from the Health Office, Operational Supervisors, Cleaning Service officers, security, sellers in stores, sellers in the canteen, and mall visitors.

Results

The results showed that the implementation of KTR at Millennium Mall was not effective. The low level of compliance from visitors and mall employees against regulations is one of the main causes. Research notes that there are still many cigarette butts scattered in the mall area, and there are employees and visitors who smoke in and around the mall. This reflects the lack of awareness and discipline in complying with existing policies.

Discussion

The results of this study indicate that the implementation of KTR at Millennium Mall is not effective. The low level of compliance from visitors and mall employees against regulations is one of the main causes. The lack of awareness and discipline in complying with existing policies is a significant factor contributing to the ineffective implementation of KTR. The study also notes that there are still many cigarette butts scattered in the mall area, and there are employees and visitors who smoke in and around the mall.

Recommendations

To increase the effectiveness of KTR implementation in Millennium Mall, the following recommendations are made:

More Intensive Promotion: Millennium Mall is advised to increase promotional efforts by increasing the installation of posters and appeals not to smoke, both inside the building and outside the mall building. This is important to increase public awareness about the importance of a smoking-free environment.
Tighter Supervision: It is recommended to prepare the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for the KTR Monitoring Team. This team needs to be trained to carry out their duties in accordance with applicable regulations, so that supervision can be carried out consistently and effectively.
Monitoring and Evaluation: It is important to conduct continuous monitoring of the implementation of KTR. The supervisory team needs to be alert in conducting an evaluation to ensure that the whole process goes according to plan. Thus, it can be seen the factors that inhibit and the steps that need to be done.

Conclusion

The implementation of non-smoking areas at the Millennium Mall is not effective. The low level of compliance from visitors and mall employees against regulations is one of the main causes. The lack of awareness and discipline in complying with existing policies is a significant factor contributing to the ineffective implementation of KTR. To increase the effectiveness of KTR implementation in Millennium Mall, the recommendations made in this study should be implemented. By implementing the above recommendations, it is expected that the implementation of non-smoking areas at the Millennium Mall can take place more effectively, so that the aim to create a healthy environment and smoke-free can be achieved.

Limitations

This study has several limitations. Firstly, the study only focuses on the Millennium Mall, which may not be representative of other KTR areas in Medan City. Secondly, the study only uses a qualitative approach, which may not provide a comprehensive understanding of the effectiveness of KTR implementation. Finally, the study only collects data from a limited number of informants, which may not be representative of the entire population.

Future Research Directions

Future research should focus on the following areas:

Quantitative Approach: Future research should use a quantitative approach to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the effectiveness of KTR implementation.
Representative Sample: Future research should collect data from a representative sample of KTR areas in Medan City to provide a more generalizable understanding of the effectiveness of KTR implementation.
Longitudinal Study: Future research should conduct a longitudinal study to examine the effectiveness of KTR implementation over time.

References

Medan City Regional Regulation No. 3 of 2014
World Health Organization. (2018). Tobacco control.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2018). Smoking & tobacco use.

Appendix

The appendix includes the following:

Informed Consent Form: The informed consent form used in this study.
Interview Guide: The interview guide used in this study.
Observation Checklist: The observation checklist used in this study.
Data Analysis Plan: The data analysis plan used in this study.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about the Effectiveness of the Implementation of Medan City Regional Regulation No. 3 of 2014 concerning Non-Smoking Areas in Medan Millennium Mall in 2018

Q: What is the purpose of Medan City Regional Regulation No. 3 of 2014?

A: The purpose of Medan City Regional Regulation No. 3 of 2014 is to create a clean and healthy space and environment, and provide protection to the people from the adverse effects of cigarettes, both directly and not directly.

Q: What are the designated KTR areas in Medan City?

A: There are seven designated KTR areas in Medan City, which must be free from cigarette smoke.

Q: What is the main cause of the ineffective implementation of KTR at Millennium Mall?

A: The low level of compliance from visitors and mall employees against regulations is one of the main causes of the ineffective implementation of KTR at Millennium Mall.

Q: What are the recommendations to increase the effectiveness of KTR implementation in Millennium Mall?

A: The recommendations to increase the effectiveness of KTR implementation in Millennium Mall include:

More Intensive Promotion: Millennium Mall is advised to increase promotional efforts by increasing the installation of posters and appeals not to smoke, both inside the building and outside the mall building.
Tighter Supervision: It is recommended to prepare the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for the KTR Monitoring Team. This team needs to be trained to carry out their duties in accordance with applicable regulations, so that supervision can be carried out consistently and effectively.
Monitoring and Evaluation: It is important to conduct continuous monitoring of the implementation of KTR. The supervisory team needs to be alert in conducting an evaluation to ensure that the whole process goes according to plan.

Q: What are the limitations of this study?

A: This study has several limitations, including:

Limited Sample Size: The study only collects data from a limited number of informants, which may not be representative of the entire population.
Qualitative Approach: The study only uses a qualitative approach, which may not provide a comprehensive understanding of the effectiveness of KTR implementation.
Limited Generalizability: The study only focuses on the Millennium Mall, which may not be representative of other KTR areas in Medan City.

Q: What are the future research directions?

A: Future research should focus on the following areas:

Quantitative Approach: Future research should use a quantitative approach to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the effectiveness of KTR implementation.
Representative Sample: Future research should collect data from a representative sample of KTR areas in Medan City to provide a more generalizable understanding of the effectiveness of KTR implementation.
Longitudinal Study: Future research should conduct a longitudinal study to examine the effectiveness of KTR implementation over time.

Q: What are the implications of this study?

A: The implications of this study are that the implementation of non-smoking areas at the Millennium Mall is not effective, and that the low level of compliance from visitors and mall employees against regulations is one of the main causes. The study also highlights the need for more intensive promotion, tighter supervision, and monitoring and evaluation to increase the effectiveness of KTR implementation.

Q: What are the recommendations for policymakers and stakeholders?

A: The recommendations for policymakers and stakeholders are to:

Increase Promotion: Increase promotional efforts to increase public awareness about the importance of a smoking-free environment.
Tighten Supervision: Prepare the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for the KTR Monitoring Team and train them to carry out their duties in accordance with applicable regulations.
Monitor and Evaluate: Conduct continuous monitoring of the implementation of KTR and evaluate the effectiveness of the implementation.

Q: What are the recommendations for future research?

A: The recommendations for future research are to:

Use a Quantitative Approach: Use a quantitative approach to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the effectiveness of KTR implementation.
Collect Data from a Representative Sample: Collect data from a representative sample of KTR areas in Medan City to provide a more generalizable understanding of the effectiveness of KTR implementation.
Conduct a Longitudinal Study: Conduct a longitudinal study to examine the effectiveness of KTR implementation over time.