The Background of Betrayal in Marriage

Oct 13, 2025 by miodeya.com 138 views

Betrayal in a Marriage as Portrayed in The Great Gatsby and Shackles: A Comparative Literature Analysis

Discussion Category: Undergraduate Theses, Education, Journal, Thesis, University, Student, Campus

Additional Information:

This article delves into the theme of betrayal in marriage as depicted in two novels, namely The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald and Shackles by Armijn Pane. Although originating from different cultural and country backgrounds, the two novels were written at a relatively close time, namely The Great Gatsby in 1925 and Shackles in 1940. Through this comparative analysis, we will explore how betrayal is portrayed in both works, as well as the similarities and differences that exist between the two.

The Background of Betrayal in Marriage

Both of these novels demonstrate that betrayal in marriage can occur due to various factors. In The Great Gatsby, we see a marriage between Tom Buchanan and Daisy, which is filled with dishonesty and poor communication. Tom, who was involved in relationships outside of his marriage, created a deep rift between him and Daisy. On the other hand, Shackles also describes the same problem, where the main character feels dissatisfied in their relationship, which is often triggered by the presence of third parties and the inability to communicate honestly.

The Portrayal of Betrayal in The Great Gatsby

Betrayal in The Great Gatsby is closely related to money symbolism and social status. Tom Buchanan, as a representation of wealth and power, utilizes his position to live a multiple life. The existence of Myrtle Wilson as a mistress woman illustrates how money can change the dynamics of relationships and create injustice in marriage. Daisy's dissatisfaction, which is trapped in an unhappy marriage, reflects the struggle of women in his day who often do not have the power to make better life decisions.

The Portrayal of Betrayal in Shackles

Conversely, in Shackles, Armijn Pane depicts betrayal with a more psychological background. The main focus on the internal conflict of the main character explains how the feeling of isolation and dissatisfaction can trigger betrayal. Here, betrayal is more rooted in emotions and communication that is not well established, which makes the character feel trapped in an unsatisfactory life. Motives like third parties and money also appear, but rather a reflection of personal dissatisfaction.

Similarities and Differences in the Portrayal of Betrayal

Through the analysis of these two novels, there are some similarities that can be identified. Firstly, both works show that betrayal is not only a physical but also an emotional problem. Both illustrate how the problem of communication and honesty is an important factor in marriage harmony. In addition, the motive of third parties is a general element that triggers betrayal in both stories.

However, the main difference lies in the way the two authors describe the social and psychological context behind betrayal. The Great Gatsby focuses more on external impacts such as social status and wealth, whereas Shackles delves deeper into psychological and emotional dynamics that affect the character. This reflects a different cultural context in which the two authors operate.

The Conclusion of the Analysis

From this analysis, it can be concluded that betrayal in marriage in both novels is caused by various motives, including the presence of third parties, money, poor communication, and lack of honesty. The works of F. Scott Fitzgerald and Armijn Pane, although different in cultural and temporal backgrounds, still convey universal messages about the complexity of human relations and how external factors can affect the dynamics of marriage. Through this understanding, readers can reflect on the importance of communication and honesty in maintaining harmony in marriage relations.

The Significance of the Analysis

This comparative analysis highlights the importance of understanding the cultural and historical context in which literature is written. By analyzing the portrayal of betrayal in The Great Gatsby and Shackles, we can gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of human relationships and the factors that contribute to betrayal in marriage. This analysis also underscores the importance of communication and honesty in maintaining harmony in marriage relations.

The Implications of the Analysis

The implications of this analysis are far-reaching. Firstly, it highlights the need for couples to communicate openly and honestly with each other in order to prevent betrayal in marriage. Secondly, it underscores the importance of recognizing the external factors that can contribute to betrayal, such as social status and wealth. Finally, it emphasizes the need for a deeper understanding of the psychological and emotional dynamics that affect human relationships.

The Future of the Analysis

This analysis provides a foundation for further research into the portrayal of betrayal in literature. Future studies can explore the portrayal of betrayal in other literary works, as well as the cultural and historical context in which these works were written. Additionally, future studies can examine the implications of this analysis for couples and individuals seeking to maintain harmony in their relationships.

The Conclusion of the Analysis

In conclusion, this comparative analysis of The Great Gatsby and Shackles highlights the complexities of human relationships and the factors that contribute to betrayal in marriage. Through this analysis, we can gain a deeper understanding of the importance of communication and honesty in maintaining harmony in marriage relations. This analysis provides a foundation for further research into the portrayal of betrayal in literature and its implications for couples and individuals seeking to maintain harmony in their relationships.
Q&A: Betrayal in Marriage as Portrayed in The Great Gatsby and Shackles

Discussion Category: Undergraduate Theses, Education, Journal, Thesis, University, Student, Campus

Additional Information:

In our previous article, we explored the theme of betrayal in marriage as depicted in two novels, namely The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald and Shackles by Armijn Pane. Through this comparative analysis, we highlighted the similarities and differences in the portrayal of betrayal in both works. In this Q&A article, we will address some of the most frequently asked questions about the analysis.

Q: What is the main theme of the analysis?

A: The main theme of the analysis is the portrayal of betrayal in marriage as depicted in The Great Gatsby and Shackles. We explored how both novels show that betrayal in marriage can occur due to various factors, including the presence of third parties, money, poor communication, and lack of honesty.

Q: What are the similarities between the two novels?

A: Both The Great Gatsby and Shackles show that betrayal is not only a physical but also an emotional problem. Both novels illustrate how the problem of communication and honesty is an important factor in marriage harmony. Additionally, the motive of third parties is a general element that triggers betrayal in both stories.

Q: What are the differences between the two novels?

A: The main difference lies in the way the two authors describe the social and psychological context behind betrayal. The Great Gatsby focuses more on external impacts such as social status and wealth, whereas Shackles delves deeper into psychological and emotional dynamics that affect the character.

Q: What are the implications of the analysis?

A: The implications of the analysis are far-reaching. Firstly, it highlights the need for couples to communicate openly and honestly with each other in order to prevent betrayal in marriage. Secondly, it underscores the importance of recognizing the external factors that can contribute to betrayal, such as social status and wealth. Finally, it emphasizes the need for a deeper understanding of the psychological and emotional dynamics that affect human relationships.

Q: What are the future directions of the analysis?

A: This analysis provides a foundation for further research into the portrayal of betrayal in literature. Future studies can explore the portrayal of betrayal in other literary works, as well as the cultural and historical context in which these works were written. Additionally, future studies can examine the implications of this analysis for couples and individuals seeking to maintain harmony in their relationships.

Q: What are the limitations of the analysis?

A: One of the limitations of the analysis is that it only focuses on two novels, The Great Gatsby and Shackles. Future studies can expand the scope of the analysis to include other literary works and explore the portrayal of betrayal in different cultural and historical contexts.

Q: What are the practical applications of the analysis?

A: The practical applications of the analysis are numerous. Firstly, it can help couples and individuals to recognize the signs of betrayal in marriage and take steps to prevent it. Secondly, it can help therapists and counselors to develop more effective strategies for treating couples and individuals who are experiencing betrayal in their relationships.

Q: What are the future research directions?

A: Future research directions can include:

Exploring the portrayal of betrayal in other literary works
Examining the cultural and historical context in which literary works were written
Investigating the implications of the analysis for couples and individuals seeking to maintain harmony in their relationships
Developing more effective strategies for treating couples and individuals who are experiencing betrayal in their relationships

Conclusion

In conclusion, this Q&A article provides a comprehensive overview of the analysis of betrayal in marriage as portrayed in The Great Gatsby and Shackles. We hope that this article will provide a useful resource for scholars, researchers, and practitioners who are interested in the topic of betrayal in marriage.