Developing a comprehensive criteria framework

Oct 13, 2025 by miodeya.com 87 views

Analysis and Design of Decision Support System for Selection of New Student X Seats with Promethee Method

Introduction

The selection of new students for class X is a crucial process that requires careful consideration of various criteria. Each student has unique competencies, and the assessment of these competencies is often carried out without using standardized parameters. This can lead to uneven competencies among selected students, which may not meet the standards of superior students. To address this issue, a decision support system (DSS) is needed that can process values based on predetermined parameters for each criterion. In this article, we will discuss the design and analysis of a DSS for the selection of new student X seats using the Promethee method.

Background

The selection of new students for class X is a complex process that involves evaluating various criteria, including academic performance, physical fitness, and personal qualities. However, the assessment of these criteria is often subjective and may not provide a comprehensive picture of a student's potential. The use of standardized parameters for each criterion can help to minimize this problem and ensure that the selection process is more objective and efficient.

Decision Support System with Promethee Method

The Promethee method is a multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) technique that can be used to evaluate and rank alternatives based on predetermined preferences and criteria. In the context of student selection, the Promethee method can be used to calculate the preference value of each student to each criterion, and then summarize it to rank. This ranking can serve as a recommendation for the selection committee to choose new class X new students.

Criteria Categories

The DSS with the Promethee method uses three criteria categories:

TPA Category

The TPA (Thinking, Problem-Solving, and Analyzing) category includes the following criteria:

Synonym
Antonym
Images
Syllogism
Analogy
Numeric sequence

These criteria are designed to assess a student's critical thinking and problem-solving skills.

Academic Test Category

The Academic Test category includes the following criteria:

Indonesian
English
Mathematics
Natural Sciences

These criteria are designed to assess a student's academic performance in various subjects.

Advanced Test Category

The Advanced Test category includes the following criteria:

Physical fitness tests
Interviews
Total national examination scores

These criteria are designed to assess a student's physical fitness, communication skills, and academic achievement.

Advantages of Decision Support Systems with Promethee Method

The use of a DSS with the Promethee method has several advantages, including:

Objectivity

The use of standardized parameters for each criterion increases the objectivity of the selection process. This ensures that the selection process is fair and unbiased.

Efficiency

The data processing process becomes more efficient and effective with this system. This is because the system can process large amounts of data quickly and accurately.

Transparency

This system increases the transparency of the selection process because each criterion and preference value can be accessed and monitored. This ensures that the selection process is transparent and accountable.

Accuracy

The Promethee method has the ability to produce more accurate ratings based on predetermined preferences and criteria. This ensures that the selection process is accurate and reliable.

Conclusion

The decision support system with the Prometheh method has the potential to improve the quality and objectivity of the selection process for new class X new students. This system can help the selection committee to choose students who are truly qualified and have the potential to become superior students. By using standardized parameters for each criterion, the system can ensure that the selection process is fair, efficient, transparent, and accurate.

Future Research Directions

Future research directions for this study include:

Developing a more comprehensive criteria framework that includes additional criteria categories.
Conducting a pilot study to test the effectiveness of the DSS with the Promethee method.
Evaluating the impact of the DSS on the selection process and student outcomes.

Limitations of the Study

This study has several limitations, including:

The study is based on a small sample size.
The study only considers three criteria categories.
The study does not evaluate the impact of the DSS on student outcomes.

Recommendations for Future Research

Based on the findings of this study, we recommend the following:

Conducting a larger-scale study to evaluate the effectiveness of the DSS with the Promethee method.
Developing a more comprehensive criteria framework that includes additional criteria categories.
Evaluating the impact of the DSS on student outcomes.

References

[List of references cited in the study]

Appendix

[Appendix includes additional information, such as data tables and figures, that support the findings of the study]
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Decision Support System for Selection of New Student X Seats with Promethee Method

Q: What is the main purpose of the Decision Support System (DSS) with Promethee method?

A: The main purpose of the DSS with Promethee method is to provide a more objective and efficient selection process for new class X new students. The system uses standardized parameters for each criterion to evaluate and rank students based on their competencies.

Q: What are the criteria categories used in the DSS with Promethee method?

A: The DSS with Promethee method uses three criteria categories:

TPA Category: Includes synonym, antonym, images, syllogism, analogy, and numeric sequence criteria.
Academic Test Category: Includes Indonesian, English, Mathematics, and Natural Sciences criteria.
Advanced Test Category: Includes physical fitness tests, interviews, and total national examination scores.

Q: How does the Promethee method work?

A: The Promethee method calculates the preference value of each student to each criterion, and then summarizes it to rank. This ranking is a recommendation for the selection committee to choose new class X new students.

Q: What are the advantages of using a DSS with Promethee method?

A: The use of a DSS with Promethee method has several advantages, including:

Objectivity: The use of standardized parameters for each criterion increases the objectivity of the selection process.
Efficiency: The data processing process becomes more efficient and effective with this system.
Transparency: This system increases the transparency of the selection process because each criterion and preference value can be accessed and monitored.
Accuracy: The Promethee method has the ability to produce more accurate ratings based on predetermined preferences and criteria.

Q: How can the DSS with Promethee method be implemented in a real-world setting?

A: The DSS with Promethee method can be implemented in a real-world setting by:

Developing a comprehensive criteria framework: This includes defining the criteria categories and parameters for each criterion.
Collecting and processing data: This involves collecting data from students and processing it using the Promethee method.
Evaluating and ranking students: This involves using the Promethee method to evaluate and rank students based on their competencies.
Providing recommendations to the selection committee: This involves providing the ranking and recommendations to the selection committee for final decision-making.

Q: What are the limitations of the DSS with Promethee method?

A: The DSS with Promethee method has several limitations, including:

Small sample size: The study is based on a small sample size, which may not be representative of the larger population.
Limited criteria categories: The study only considers three criteria categories, which may not be comprehensive enough to capture all aspects of student competencies.
No evaluation of student outcomes: The study does not evaluate the impact of the DSS on student outcomes, such as academic performance and career success.

Q: What are the future research directions for the DSS with Promethee method?

A: Future research directions for the DSS with Promethee method include:

Developing a more comprehensive criteria framework: This includes defining additional criteria categories and parameters for each criterion.
Conducting a larger-scale study: This involves collecting data from a larger sample size to evaluate the effectiveness of the DSS with Promethee method.
Evaluating the impact of the DSS on student outcomes: This involves evaluating the impact of the DSS on student outcomes, such as academic performance and career success.

Q: How can the DSS with Promethee method be used in other contexts?

A: The DSS with Promethee method can be used in other contexts, such as:

Employee selection: The DSS with Promethee method can be used to evaluate and rank employees based on their competencies and qualifications.
Student admissions: The DSS with Promethee method can be used to evaluate and rank students based on their academic performance and other criteria.
Grant funding: The DSS with Promethee method can be used to evaluate and rank grant proposals based on their merit and potential impact.